Behaviour

Response Generalization: What it is and why it's important

Just What is Response Generalization Anyway?

Technical definitions of response generalization can be difficult to understand so I will start with two examples of response generalization. In my early teens I was taught to type on a keyboard. Much later, I used those same typing skills to learn how to use swipe-to-text on my phone. Here’s another example. I learned about street safety as a child during a course in elementary school with my bike. I started using the same safety skills when walking. Now the definition. Essentially, response generalization has occurred when a person uses a new skill, that can be similar to a known skill, to access a known consequence. Let’s break down these 2 examples;

Example 1

I was taught to drive in a specific car. It was a manual and sometimes the engine would turn off on a left turn. When I finally got another car, I learned to drive it, despite it being an automatic and the engine staying on. 

Example 2

Did you have a street safety course in elementary or primary school? Our parking lot was made to look like a city block, with streets, fake shops, and street signs. Those of us with bikes were asked to bring them and everyone else walked. I had a bike and learned how to navigate streets. About a year later we moved somewhere new and much closer to the school so I stopped riding my bike. I used the same safety rules I learned on my bike, while walking in a new place.

Doesn't Response Generalization Happen on Its Own?

For many people, response generalization happens naturally. Driving a car is a perfect example. No one had to specifically teach you how to drive each car, but sometimes it isn’t that easy. Individuals with developmental disorders tend to struggle with spontaneous generalization and benefit strongly from ABA programs that specifically teach for response generalization (Pratt, Wickerd, & Steege, 2019).

Why is Response Generalization important?

Response generalization is important and often an explicit goal of ABA intervention because it allows individuals to independently use new versions of skills they have been taught in situations where a known consequence is available; like the example of me learning to use swipe-to-text on my phone by myself after being taught to type on a keyboard. The effect of response generalization helps  extend the effects of ABA intervention to new environments where ABA services may not be available. To put it another way, the skills being taught in any specific environment, like the clinic or the school, are more likely to be used in other places, like the home and the community, when response generalization is a goal in treatment.

How Do You Support Response Generalization?

Supporting Generalization is a major goal of ABA treatment and is addressed throughout the entire course of treatment (Pratt, Wickerd, & Steege, 2019). Let’s look at an example first and talk about the steps after. When you are teaching a child to ride a bike, you may start with training wheels, or you may hold onto them. You will also likely stay relatively close to your home, likely on your street. As your child gets more stable, you may remove a training wheel, or a hand. If they remain upright you may remove both training wheels or let go. If they stay up, they may start to ride further and further away from the house.

The idea is that you support the child as they are learning a skill (it doesn’t have to be bike riding) while being thoughtful of the places and situations where they will eventually use the skill. If I wanted to teach someone a skill I would use these basic steps. Let’s use the example of “riding a bike” used above.

  • Use a variety of examples of any materials used in the skill

In the case of riding a bike there are a few different things used, from bikes, to helmets, to safety and road signs. It is important to make sure that the child you are teaching has exposure to different types of all of these materials, like seeing or using different bikes or helmets.

  • Practice using the skill in different places and situations

When teaching someone to ride a bike, it would be important to make sure that they practice to ride in a few places, like on their home street, at an intersection, or at a stoplight. It is impossible to take your child for supervised practice everywhere they will ever ride a bike. What is important is to practice at places they will encounter that are similar everywhere you ride a bike, like responding to a stop sign.  

  • Make sure the person knows when they can, and can’t, use the skill

When teaching any skill it is important to also teach times and situations where using the skill is appropriate, as well as teaching times and situations that are not appropriate. For riding a bike every family will be different and that is okay. It is important to be clear about when bike riding can, and cannot, take place like; “Be home before dinner” or “You can ride your bike after you finish your homework and chores”. This also includes rewarding the child for riding their bike during the correct times (it can be simple, like saying, “You are so fast on your bike! Nice work!”)

Making it Fun

When your child learns a new skill, be energetic and animated for them to show you the skill. Have them practice the skill, or practice with them, using different materials, like encouraging a child using pencils to try using paint. It can serve as quality time together that also serves a purpose of helping your child become more independent and flexible. Response generalization can also be an incredibly rewarding experience to be a part of. Being part of a child’s play when they learn that they can do things on their own is really special. 

References

Pratt, J. L., Wickerd, G. D., & Steege, M. W. (2019). Generalization and maintenance. In S. G. Little & A. Akin-Little (Eds.), Applying psychology in the schools book series. Behavioral interventions in schools: Evidence-based positive strategies (p. 97–111). American Psychological Association. https://doi.org/10.1037/0000126-006


Behaviour Intervention Plans: What They are and Why They are Useful

What is a Behaviour Intervention Plan?

A Behaviour Intervention Plan (BIP) is an outline that describes, monitors and aims to replace a targeted behaviour. A targeted behaviour is typically one that is harmful or inappropriate, and causes disruption in other aspects of daily life. Targeted behaviours can include non-compliance, tantrums, and self-injurious behaviours. By creating a BIP after an assessment of the client, behaviour analysts are able to determine and describe the target behaviour, and create a treatment plan to decrease the occurrence of said behaviour. Every BIP is specific to the client, meaning we decide what intervention approach to use based on the strengths and needs of each individual. We realize each individual learns differently, which is why we spend quality time ensuring the BIP is the best practice for that client. 

Breaking Down a BIP

Now, when looking at a BIP for the first time, it may seem daunting and confusing. Let’s break it down into the individual components, along with an example to really paint a picture of what exactly a BIP looks like. For example purposes, we will use the random name “Bobby” as our client.

Date: The date the BIP was created.

Ex: 15 April 2018

Behaviour: The target behaviour we are aiming to reduce, and the setting we are working in, i.e. at home, school or in the clinic.

Ex: Tantrum (Clinic)

Operational Definition: Defining the behaviour in a way that can be observed and measured.

Ex: Any episode of crying, flopping to the floor, disrupting objects and/or screaming. Onset is 10 seconds; offset is when he’s calm for 30 seconds. Does not include crying when he is hurt.

Measurement: How we measure the behaviour appropriately; do we measure how often the behaviour occurs, or how long the behaviour occurs for? (These are a few examples, among others, of how we can measure a behaviour).

Ex: Duration

Functional Behaviour Assessment Date: The date the client was assessed to determine the “where”, “when” and “why” of their challenging behaviour.

Ex: 14 April 2018

Function(s): The “why”, or the reason behind, the target/challenging behaviour.

Ex: Attention and Escape 

Function Statement: Specifically describing the function of behaviour.

  Ex: Bobby engages in tantrum behaviour to escape non-preferred tasks, and to gain attention from therapists/peers.

Baseline: Data collected before the intervention starts. 

Ex: January 2018: Baseline data was taken over a period of 10 days and 25 individual sessions in the clinic. Bobby engaged in tantrum 55% of sessions, ranging in duration from 0 seconds to 55 minutes. 

Current Goal: The goal, which is specific, measurable, achievable, realistic and timely, in place for the target behaviour.  

Ex: By August 2018, the behaviour of tantrums will last no longer than 1 minute per episode in the clinic setting, across two different therapists, for a period of 2 weeks. 

Progress: The data collected to determine whether or not the client has made progress with the intervention plan. If this is a new behaviour plan, this section will not be applicable until therapy has started. 

Ex: N/A, as this is a new goal and behaviour plan. 

The next 3 sections of the BIP are the specific intervention strategies used for the client, and are all based on the client’s specific strengths and areas of need. 

Antecedent Manipulations: Preventative strategies must be done before the behaviour happens, not as a reaction to it.

Functionally Equivalent Replacement Behaviour(s): Replacement behaviours are the healthy behaviours we are reinforcing, instead of the challenging/target behaviour we are trying to decrease 

Consequence Manipulations: Reactive strategies are planned responses that all stakeholders must follow, across all environments 

Putting it all Together: Why do we use a BIP?

A BIP is an essential element of ABA therapy. The BIP provides us with all the information needed to implement a behaviour plan and monitor the client’s targeted behaviour(s). As time goes on, we analyze the data taken during therapy sessions, and determine if this behaviour plan is allowing the client to make any progress towards the current goal. If progress is not being made, behaviour analysts will take a step back, and make changes accordingly. A client’s BIP is the foundational resource that is used to ensure the best practices and measures are implemented for their specific needs.

Prompting: Part 2

Prompting Appropriately and Prompt Fading

How do I know when to prompt?

When teaching a new skill, keep in mind that many children may have difficulties completing the task or skill independently. This is where prompts come in, as we use them to assist the client and guide them to choosing the correct response, or complete the task successfully. If a stimulus is presented and there is either no response, or an incorrect response from the client, this is our signal to incorporate a prompt into the next trial. We may start out with a small prompt, and increase the level of intrusiveness if the learner is still giving incorrect responses. On the other hand, we may start out with the most intrusive prompt if we are teaching a brand new skill. Regardless, we always have to be cautious about how we use prompts and if we are using them appropriately. All in all, the goal is to eventually fade all prompts out, and the learner can choose the correct response independently.

Prompt Hierarchy 

A prompt hierarchy helps us decide what prompt to begin with, and which prompts to use to either increase or decrease the level of assistance the learner may need. The prompt hierarchy begins with the prompt that is the most intrusive, or provides the most amount of assistance to complete a task or select the correct response. As the prompt hierarchy continues, the prompts become less and less intrusive, allowing the learner to have more independence. The prompt hierarchy can also start from the bottom, with the least intrusive prompt, and work its way up if the learner requires more assistance. The prompt hierarchy looks like so, starting with the most intrusive prompt:

  • Full Physical 

  • Partial Physical

  • Proximity

  • Modeling

  • Gestural

  • Visual 

  • Full Verbal

  • Partial Verbal

For more information about what each of these prompts look like, visit this blog.

Least to Most

The least-to-most prompt approach is used when the learner already shows similar skills to the new skill being introduced. These similar skills are called “component skills”, meaning they are the base or foundation skills needed to learn new things. Least-to-most prompting is usually preferred, unless component skills are not exhibited by the learner. As behaviour therapists, we want to use the least intrusive prompt first, as this will help promote independence. Once the stimulus or signal is delivered to the learner, the therapist will use a prompt towards the bottom of the prompt hierarchy, such as an eye gaze, and continue to use a more intrusive prompt if necessary. A more intrusive prompt, such as moving the correct response closer, will be used if the correct response was not selected on the previous trial. A least to most prompt technique may look something like this:

Eye gaze → hand gesture → move correct response closer → taking learners hand and placing it on the correct response 

Most to Least

We use most-to-least prompting when a learner is just beginning to learn a new skill. This approach is used for a technique called “errorless learning”, which ensures there is no chance the learner will choose the incorrect response. In errorless learning, prompts are delivered very quickly and swiftly, typically less than 3 seconds after the stimulus is delivered. This allows the learner to choose the correct response, and the prompts can quickly be faded out. A most to least prompt technique may look something like this:

Hand over hand → move correct response closer → point to correct response → no prompt needed 

Prompt fading: Avoiding Prompt Dependency 

While prompts are a great way to encourage our clients, we want to ensure they do not start relying on the prompts to make a correct response. In other words, we do not want them to become prompt dependent, rather we want them to be making independent choices. Prompt fading can occur in two different ways; it can be data driven or client led. When prompts are data driven, we specifically plan out which prompt will be used at what time. We can plan to use gestural prompts today, and use visual prompts tomorrow. This gives us a clear timeline of which prompts were used and when they were used. On the other hand, prompt fading can also be client led. When prompt fading is client led, we gradually fade the prompts when the client has mastered the skill at the current prompt level. For example, if we are teaching a child how to brush their teeth using a hand over hand prompt, once they have mastered how to hold and maneuver their toothbrush, we can now fade the prompt to a less intrusive, say a gestural prompt of pointing to the toothbrush, and eventually no prompt at all. Prompt fading promotes independence in our learners, and once they have mastered the skill, there is no need for prompts at all!